Process
Areas
(staged)

Level 2
 RM
 ARD
 PP
 PMC
 AM
 SSAD
 MA
 PPQA
 CM
Level 3
 ATM
 AVER
 AVAL
 OPF
 OPD
 OT
 IPM
 RSKM
 DAR
Level 4
 OPP
 QPM
Level 5
 OID
 CAR

 SP 1.4 Select Evaluation Methods
Process AreaDAR
Level3
GoalSG 1
PracticeSP 1.4

Select evaluation methods.

Methods for evaluating alternative solutions against established criteria can range from simulations to the use of probabilistic models and decision theory. These methods must be carefully selected. The level of detail of a method should be commensurate with cost, schedule, performance, and risk impacts.

While many problems may require only one evaluation method, some problems may require multiple methods. For instance, simulations may augment a trade study to determine which design alternative best meets a given criterion.

Suppliers competing to develop a technical solution for the acquirer may be directly evaluated in a final competition that involves a performance or functional demonstration of proposed solutions.

Typical Work Products

1.    Selected evaluation methods

Subpractices

1.    Select methods based on the purpose for analyzing a decision and on the availability of the information used to support the method.

Typical evaluation methods include the following:

·       Benchmarking studies

·       Cost studies

·       Business opportunity studies

·       Surveys

·       Extrapolations based on field experience and prototypes

·       User review and comment

·       Judgment provided by an expert or group of experts (e.g., Delphi Method)

 

2.    Select evaluation methods based on their ability to focus on the issues at hand without being overly influenced by side issues.

3.    Determine the measures needed to support the evaluation method.

Refer to the Measurement and Analysis process area for more information about specifying measures.

Table  | Images  | Glossary  | Index  | Faceted index


Process
Areas(continuous)

Process
management  
 OPF
 OPD
 OT  
 OPP 
 OID
Project
management
 PP
 PMC
 IPM
 QPM
 RSKM
 REQM
Acquisition
 AM
 SSAD 
 ARD
 ATM
 AVER
 AVAL
Support
 CM
 PPQA
 MA
 DAR
 CAR